Not recognized by WWE
| # | Wrestler | Date | Place | Special Note |
| 1 | Ted DiBiase | February 15, 1989 | Binghamton, New York | 1 |
| 2 | Virgil | August 26, 1991 | New York City, New York | |
| 3 | Ted DiBiase(2) | November 11, 1991 | Utica, New York | 2 |
| 4 | Ringmaster(Steve Austin) | January 8, 1996 | Newark, Delaware | 3 |
| 5 | Savio Vega | May 28, 1996 | North Charleston, South Carolina | 4 |
Notes:
1. Title was created for and by "Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase.
2. Title was abandoned by DiBiase when he won the Tag Team Championship on February 7, 1992.
3. The title was awarded to Ringmaster.
4. Vega abandoned the title shortly following his victory. Title then becomes retired.
